Skip to main content
    Audit & assurance

    What is a management letter and what should you do with it?

    The auditor's management letter lists control weaknesses found during the audit. How Cambodian companies should prioritise, assign owners and close findings before they recur.

    Published
    Published 4 September 2026
    Updated
    Updated 4 September 2026
    12 min read

    What is a management letter and what should you do with it?

    A management letter, also called the report to those charged with governance, is the auditor's private list of control weaknesses and other findings noticed during the audit. It is separate from the audit opinion and is not filed with ACAR. Treat it as a work plan: give every finding an owner and a deadline, fix the ones that touch cash and tax first, and expect the auditor to check the same points next year.

    In short

    • The management letter is separate from the opinion; a company can receive an unmodified opinion and a long letter in the same week.
    • Typical Cambodian findings: cash handling, unreconciled accounts, cut-off, related-party documentation, tax returns that do not agree to the ledger, missing Khmer documents.
    • Prioritise by exposure: cash and tax first, then reporting quality, then efficiency.
    • Findings recur when nobody owns them; a one-page tracker with an owner and a deadline for each stops that.
    • The same weaknesses surface in a GDT tax audit, so closing them protects the company twice.

    What the management letter is, and what it is not

    During an audit the auditor learns a great deal about how a company's records are kept, and the auditing standards require the auditor to report the deficiencies in internal control that come to light, in writing, to management and to those charged with governance. That written communication is the management letter. In a company with a board or an audit committee it may be addressed to them and called the report to those charged with governance; in an owner-managed business it goes to the owners. It usually lists each finding, the risk it creates, a recommendation, and a column for management's response.

    It is not part of the audited financial statements and it is not filed with ACAR. Only the auditor's report and the financial statements are filed, by 15 July for a December year-end where Prakas 563 applies. It is also not an opinion on the company's internal controls: the auditor did not set out to review every control, only to audit the financial statements, and the letter records what was noticed on the way. A short letter does not mean the controls are good, and a long one does not mean the opinion is in doubt. The two documents answer different questions.

    Alongside control findings the letter often records the adjustments made during the audit, any misstatements management chose not to correct, and disagreements over accounting treatment. Those parts tell the board how close the draft accounts were to the final ones, which is itself a measure of the finance function.

    The findings that recur in Cambodian companies

    The pattern of findings in Phnom Penh is consistent enough to predict. Most trace to a small finance team doing many things, to records kept in two currencies and two languages, and to a tax system that files monthly and audits later.

    • Cash handling: cash sales, petty cash and cash in both US dollars and Khmer riel with no daily count, no independent check and no record that can be agreed to the ledger.
    • Reconciliations: bank accounts not reconciled each month, or reconciled by the same person who posts the entries, so that errors and missing receipts go unnoticed until the auditor arrives.
    • Cut-off: sales, purchases and stock movements around the year end recorded in the wrong period, so that revenue, cost of sales and payables are misstated in opposite directions across two years.
    • Related-party documentation: management fees, loans and shared costs with the parent or with sister companies that have no agreement, no evidence of the service received and no transfer pricing support under Prakas 986 MEF.Prk.
    • Tax filings that do not agree to the ledger: the sales on the VAT returns differ from revenue in the accounts, the payroll on the tax on salary returns differs from the payroll ledger, and rent paid to a resident landlord does not appear on the withholding tax returns.
    • Supporting documents: invoices and contracts missing, held only as informal receipts, or not available in the Khmer form the GDT will expect to see.
    • Housekeeping: no fixed-asset register, no inventory count records, journal entries posted without approval, and accounting system access shared between staff.

    How to prioritise and respond

    A letter with fifteen findings cannot be fixed in one month, and a board that tries to will fix none of them. Sort the findings into three groups. First, anything that exposes the company to loss or to tax: cash controls, and every finding where a return does not agree to the ledger. Second, anything that affects the reliability of the accounts: reconciliations, cut-off, provisions, the fixed-asset register. Third, efficiency and housekeeping. Work down the list in that order.

    Respond to each finding in writing, in the response column the auditor provides. Say whether management agrees, what will be done, who will do it and by when. Where management disagrees, say so and explain why; the auditor may accept the explanation or may repeat the finding, and either way the board has a record. Responses such as 'management will monitor' are not actions and should not be accepted as such by the board.

    1. 01Read the letter with the finance manager and the auditor in the same room, so that each finding is understood the same way by everyone.
    2. 02Sort the findings: exposure to loss or tax first, reliability of the accounts second, housekeeping third.
    3. 03Assign one named owner to each finding, never a department, and agree a deadline that is tied to an event: the next month-end close, the next monthly return, the next board meeting.
    4. 04Write the response in the letter and copy the findings into a tracker the board reviews at each meeting.
    5. 05Test each fix before the next audit, so the auditor is shown evidence of a control that works rather than told about one that was planned.

    Why findings recur, and how to stop it

    Auditors see the same findings return year after year for a handful of reasons. No one was named as owner, so the finding belonged to everyone and to no one. The finance manager who understood the point left, and the letter left with them. The fix was described as training rather than as a control, so nothing changed in the system. The letter was read once at the closing meeting, filed, and not looked at again until the auditor asked about it the following year.

    The remedy is administrative rather than clever. Keep a single tracker with one line per finding, review it at every board or management meeting, and connect the fixes to the month-end close checklist so that the new control is performed twelve times before the auditor returns, not once. The table shows the shape; the content will be the company's own.

    A simple findings tracker, with illustrative rows
    FindingRiskOwnerDeadline
    Bank accounts not reconciled monthlyErrors and missing receipts go unnoticed; VAT and prepayment returns are prepared from unreconciled figuresFinance managerEach month, before the returns due on the 20th
    Cash sales recorded from memory, no daily countCash loss; undeclared sales found in a tax auditOperations managerBefore the next month-end close
    Management fee to the parent with no agreementDeduction challenged; transfer pricing documentation under Prakas 986 MEF.Prk incompleteManaging directorBefore the annual tax on income return due 31 March
    Rent paid to an individual landlord with nothing withheldThe tenant owes the 10% withholding tax under Prakas 518 MEF.PrkFinance managerThe next monthly withholding tax return
    Goods received in the last week of December invoiced in JanuaryCut-off error in cost of sales and payablesWarehouse supervisor and finance managerCut-off procedure agreed before the year-end count

    What changes when the same auditor returns

    A returning auditor starts from last year's letter. Each prior finding is followed up, and the new letter says whether it was resolved, partly resolved or repeated. A repeated finding is reported as such, and a finding repeated for several years is, in substance, a finding about governance rather than about bookkeeping, because the board has seen it before and has not made it go away.

    Persistent weaknesses also change the audit itself. Where the auditor cannot rely on a control, more of the work moves to detailed testing of transactions and balances, which takes longer and asks more of the finance team. Where the weakness means evidence does not exist at all, cash with no records for instance, the question stops being one for the management letter and becomes one for the opinion, because the auditor cannot obtain the evidence the standards require.

    The reverse is also true. A company that closes its findings gives the auditor controls to rely on, produces fewer adjustments, and reaches the signed report with less disruption each year. That is the practical case for treating the management letter as a plan rather than as a formality.

    A repeated finding is a governance finding

    When the same weakness appears in consecutive letters, the question for the board is no longer how to fix it but why it was not fixed. Ask for the tracker, the owner and the evidence of the control working, and treat the absence of any of the three as the real finding.

    Key facts

    What it is
    The auditor's written report of control deficiencies and other findings from the audit
    Also called the report to those charged with governance.
    Relationship to the opinion
    Separate; it does not change the opinion
    An unmodified opinion and a long letter often arrive together.
    Filed with ACAR?
    No
    Only the auditor's report and the financial statements are filed, by 15 July where Prakas 563 applies.
    Who receives it
    Management and those charged with governance
    The board, an audit committee or the owners.
    Typical Cambodian findings
    Cash handling, reconciliations, cut-off, related-party documentation, returns not agreeing to the ledger, missing Khmer documents
    Effective response
    One owner and one deadline per finding, tracked monthly
    Fix exposure to loss and tax first.

    How this article is checked

    Figures were verified against the sources listed below in September 2026 and are re-checked each January or when the rule changes. Written by the Fourmi & Partners tax and audit team. General information, not advice on your situation: for that, talk to a partner.

    Questions

    Questions people ask

    No. It is a private communication from the auditor to management and those charged with governance. Only the auditor's report and the audited financial statements are filed with ACAR, by 15 July for a December year-end where the Prakas 563 thresholds are met. A bank or a parent company may ask to see the letter under the terms of their agreements.

    Yes, and most companies do. The opinion says the financial statements are true and fair in all material respects; the letter says how the records that produced them could be kept better. The two documents answer different questions, and a clean opinion does not mean the controls are sound.

    No. Respond to each one in writing: agree and say what will be done, or disagree and say why. The auditor may accept the explanation or repeat the finding next year. What the board should not accept is a response that describes no action, because that is how findings become permanent.

    The board or the owners, the finance manager and, where there is one, the audit committee. A parent company will normally want it for group reporting. Sharing it with the people who own the fixes, rather than filing it with the audit correspondence, is what turns it into a plan.

    The management letter is a by-product of the financial statement audit: it records the control deficiencies the auditor happened to encounter while auditing the accounts. An internal audit or a controls review sets out to examine the controls themselves and covers ground the external audit does not. A short management letter is therefore not evidence that the controls are complete.

    Usually. Controls the auditor can rely on mean less detailed testing, fewer adjustments and a faster route to the signed report, and the same fixes remove the most common findings in a GDT tax audit. Fees and timetables are matters for the engagement letter, but the connection between clean records and a smooth audit is direct.
    Sources

    Where the rules come from

    1. 01Cambodian International Standards on Auditing — Kampuchea Institute of Certified Public Accountants and Auditors (KICPAA)
    2. 02International Standards on Auditing: communicating deficiencies in internal control to those charged with governance and management — International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB)
    3. 03Law on Accounting and Auditing (2016) — Kingdom of Cambodia
    4. 04Prakas 563 MEF.Prk on the obligation to have financial statements audited (10 July 2020) — Ministry of Economy and Finance
    5. 05Law on Taxation (2023) — Kingdom of Cambodia. Tax audit, reassessment and the returns the GDT reconciles
    Next step

    Talk to a partner about your situation

    Articles explain the rule; a partner can tell you how it applies to your company, in Khmer, English or Chinese. First call is free.

    Cookies on this site

    Essential cookies only, unless you allow analytics or advertising.