In short
- Four opinions: unmodified, qualified, adverse and disclaimer, in descending order of comfort.
- Unmodified means true and fair in all material respects; it does not mean every figure is exact or that the business is sound.
- A qualified opinion is limited to the matter described in the basis for opinion paragraph; read that before reacting.
- Emphasis of matter and going concern paragraphs draw attention to something without changing the opinion.
- A Cambodian statutory audit follows CISA, is signed by a KICPAA-registered partner and is filed with ACAR by 15 July where Prakas 563 applies.
What the opinion is, and what it is not
The auditor's report is a short document attached to the front of the financial statements, and the opinion is its first paragraph. It answers one question: do these financial statements, taken as a whole, give a true and fair view of the company's position and performance under the framework they were prepared under? In Cambodia that framework is CIFRS or CIFRS for SMEs, the National Accounting Council's adoptions of IFRS and IFRS for SMEs.
Two phrases carry the weight. 'True and fair' means the figures are supported by what actually happened and the presentation does not mislead, whether by what it shows or by what it leaves out. 'In all material respects' means the auditor is speaking about errors large enough, or important enough, to change what a reader would decide; it is not a promise that every figure is exact. The auditor sets a materiality level for the engagement and designs the work around it, and the figure is not published in the report.
The opinion is not a statement that the business is profitable, well managed, solvent for the foreseeable future or a good credit. Those are judgements the reader makes from the statements once the auditor has said they can be relied upon. It is also not a check of every transaction; the auditor obtains reasonable assurance, which is a high level, from testing, confirmation and analysis, not certainty.
The four opinions and what each tells a bank, a parent or ACAR
An unmodified opinion is the standard result. Everything else is a modified opinion, and the auditing standards give the auditor three forms of modification, chosen according to two questions: is the problem a misstatement the auditor found, or evidence the auditor could not get; and is it confined to one area, or does it spread through the statements as a whole?
A confined problem produces a qualified opinion: the statements are true and fair 'except for' the matter described. A problem that runs through the whole picture produces an adverse opinion, where the auditor has evidence the statements are materially misstated, or a disclaimer, where the auditor could not obtain enough evidence to form any opinion at all. A disclaimer says nothing about whether the figures are right; it says the auditor cannot tell.
| Opinion | What the auditor is saying | What it tells a bank, a parent or ACAR |
|---|---|---|
| Unmodified | The financial statements are true and fair in all material respects. | The statements can be relied on as a whole. Read the notes and any emphasis of matter or going concern paragraph, which can sit under an unmodified opinion. |
| Qualified | Except for one described matter, the statements are true and fair. The matter is either a confined misstatement or an area where evidence was not available. | Rely on the rest; look hard at the matter. A bank will ask about it, a parent may adjust for it on consolidation, and the qualification is visible to ACAR on the filed statements. |
| Adverse | The statements are materially misstated and the effect is pervasive; they do not give a true and fair view. | Do not rely on the statements. Lenders usually treat this as a breach of reporting covenants and a group auditor cannot use the figures without further work. |
| Disclaimer of opinion | The auditor could not obtain enough evidence to form an opinion, and the possible effects are pervasive. | The reader learns nothing about the figures except that they could not be verified. Usually the result of missing records, denied access or a fundamental uncertainty. |
The basis for opinion and key audit matters
Directly under the opinion sits the basis for opinion. For an unmodified report it is largely standard wording: the audit was conducted under the Cambodian International Standards on Auditing, the auditor is independent of the company under the applicable ethical requirements, and the evidence obtained is sufficient and appropriate. For a modified report the paragraph is where the substance lives. It describes the matter, quantifies its effect where that can be done, or explains why it cannot, and states whether the problem was a misstatement or a lack of evidence.
Anyone handed a qualified report should read the basis paragraph before the opinion itself, because it defines how far the qualification reaches. A qualification over the valuation of one warehouse of inventory says nothing about cash, receivables or revenue; the auditor has confined it deliberately.
Some reports also contain key audit matters: a section describing the areas that, in the auditor's judgement, required the most attention during the audit, and how the auditor dealt with them. The standards require it for listed entities and allow it where the engagement calls for it; most private companies in Cambodia will not see one. A key audit matter is not a qualification and not a criticism. It tells the reader where the audit effort went, which is often where the accounting judgement is hardest.
Emphasis of matter and going concern paragraphs
An emphasis of matter paragraph draws the reader's attention to something that is properly disclosed in the financial statements and that the auditor considers fundamental to understanding them: a significant event after the year end, a change of accounting framework, a major legal dispute described in the notes. It does not modify the opinion. The auditor is pointing, not disagreeing.
Going concern has its own paragraph. If events or conditions cast significant doubt on the company's ability to continue for the foreseeable future, and the financial statements disclose that uncertainty adequately, the auditor includes a paragraph headed material uncertainty related to going concern and leaves the opinion unmodified. If the disclosure is inadequate, or the auditor disagrees with the going concern basis altogether, the opinion is modified instead.
Readers should not treat an unmodified opinion with a going concern paragraph as a clean report. A bank will read the paragraph as the most important sentence in the document. For a subsidiary, the paragraph is often avoided by a written undertaking of support from the parent, which the auditor will want to see and assess, so a Cambodian company that depends on group funding should raise the point with its parent before fieldwork, not during it.
The Cambodian frame: CISA, KICPAA and ACAR
A statutory audit in Cambodia is conducted under the Cambodian International Standards on Auditing, CISA, the local adoption of the International Standards on Auditing, and the report is signed by an engagement partner registered with the Kampuchea Institute of Certified Public Accountants and Auditors, KICPAA. The registration is personal, so the name on the report can be checked against the KICPAA register. The framework for the statements themselves is CIFRS or CIFRS for SMEs, and the auditor's report says which.
Audited financial statements are filed with the Accounting and Auditing Regulator, ACAR, by 15 July for a December year-end, where the enterprise meets two of the three thresholds in Prakas 563 MEF.Prk of 10 July 2020: annual turnover above KHR 4 billion, total assets above KHR 3 billion, or more than 100 employees. The filing obligation is met by any of the four opinions; ACAR receives a qualified report as readily as an unmodified one. What differs is what the regulator, and anyone else who reads the file, learns from it.
The annual tax on income return is due earlier, by 31 March, so it is usually prepared from draft accounts before the audit report is signed. Where the audit produces adjustments, or a qualification that points to a misstatement, the tax computation needs a second look. A tax auditor from the GDT may also ask to see the audited statements, and a qualification over revenue or inventory will not go unnoticed there.
How to read a qualified opinion without panic
A qualified opinion is not a failed audit. It is the auditor saying that the statements are reliable except for one defined matter, and the useful response is to understand that matter precisely and to decide what it means for the people who will read the report. Most qualifications in practice trace to evidence that did not exist or could not be reached, not to dishonesty.
The most common example in a first statutory audit is opening balances: the auditor was not present at the previous year-end inventory count, so cannot verify the opening stock, so cannot verify the year's cost of sales. That qualification usually disappears in the second year. A qualification that repeats, or that concerns the current year's records, is a different signal and deserves a different response.
- 01Read the basis for qualified opinion paragraph and write down, in one sentence, what is qualified and what is not.
- 02Establish whether the matter is a misstatement the auditor found or evidence the auditor could not obtain, and whether it belongs to this year or to a prior period.
- 03Ask the auditor what evidence, or what correction, would have removed the qualification, and whether that can be done before the statements are filed.
- 04Work out what the qualification means for loan covenants, group reporting and the tax computation, and tell the bank and the parent before they read it themselves.
- 05Put the cause on the management letter action list with an owner, so that next year's report does not repeat it.
The opinion cannot be negotiated; the evidence can be improved
An auditor can sign only what the evidence supports. Asking for a different opinion achieves nothing, but producing the missing reconciliation, arranging the confirmation or correcting the statements before the report is signed often does. The time to do that is before year end, not after fieldwork.
What management can do before year end to avoid one
Almost every qualification has a preventable cause that was visible months before the audit. Bank accounts that were never reconciled; an inventory count the auditor was not invited to attend; a fixed-asset register that does not exist; balances with related parties that no one confirmed; revenue recorded in the wrong period; supporting documents missing or held only as informal receipts rather than the invoices the auditor, and the GDT, expect to see. None of these can be fixed in the week the report is due.
The remedy is to run the year as if the audit were continuous: close the books monthly, agree count dates with the auditor before the year end, arrange bank and related-party confirmations early, and settle accounting policy questions, on revenue recognition or impairment for instance, while there is still time to gather evidence for the position taken. Where management and the auditor disagree on a treatment, the disagreement should be surfaced in the planning meeting, not discovered in the draft report.
A company facing its first audit under Prakas 563 should read the article on preparing for a first statutory audit, because opening balances are where first-year qualifications come from. A company that has been audited before should start with last year's management letter: it is the auditor's own list of what would otherwise become this year's qualification.
Key facts
- The four opinions
- Unmodified, qualified, adverse, disclaimer of opinion
- Qualified means confined to a described matter; adverse and disclaimer mean the effect is pervasive.
- Auditing standards
- Cambodian International Standards on Auditing (CISA)
- The local adoption of the International Standards on Auditing.
- Who signs
- A KICPAA-registered engagement partner
- The registration is personal and can be checked.
- Reporting framework
- CIFRS or CIFRS for SMEs
- The National Accounting Council's adoptions of IFRS and IFRS for SMEs.
- Filing
- ACAR, by 15 July for a December year-end
- Where two of the three Prakas 563 thresholds are met.
- Going concern paragraph
- Draws attention; does not by itself modify the opinion
- Provided the uncertainty is adequately disclosed in the statements.
How this article is checked
Figures were verified against the sources listed below in September 2026 and are re-checked each January or when the rule changes. Written by the Fourmi & Partners tax and audit team. General information, not advice on your situation: for that, talk to a partner.